Skip to main content
Share

In Cocona, Inc. v. VF Outdoor, LLC, Nos. 2025-1458, 2025-1462 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 17, 2026), the Federal Circuit affirmed a district court’s determination that claims of U.S. Patent No. 8,945,287 were invalid for indefiniteness under 35 U.S.C. § 112[i]. The patent relates to waterproof, breathable membranes used in products such as outdoor apparel. The claimed membranes purportedly improved breathability over prior-art membranes by incorporating active particles. A common performance measure of waterproof membranes is moisture vapor transmission rate (MVTR). The asserted claims required the membranes to have an MVTR ranging from about 600 to about 11,000 g/m²/day. The specification disclosed multiple methods for measuring MVTR, including an upright cup method, an inverted cup method, and the Mocon method, but the patent failed to provide sufficient guidance as to which method should be used to determine whether a membrane satisfied the claimed range. The patent also failed to provide sufficient guidance as to the testing conditions, such as temperature and relative humidity, under which MVTR should be measured. Although the specification referenced the ASTM E96-94 standard, that standard permits testing under a range of temperature and humidity conditions and cautions that an MVTR value measured under one set of test conditions may not indicate the value under a different set of conditions. Importantly, the specification demonstrated that different methods can produce substantially different results for the same material. In fact, a material could fall within the claimed MVTR range when measured using one method but outside the claimed range when measured using another. Because the choice of measurement method and testing conditions could determine whether a product infringed the claims, the Federal Circuit held that the claims failed to inform those skilled in the art of their scope with reasonable certainty[ii].

Cocona sought to resolve the uncertainty surrounding the different measurement methods by arguing during claim construction that the MVTR limitation should be construed to require measurement according to the ASTM E96 MVTR cup water test method at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity over a 24-hour period, using the upright method for low moisture contact and the inverted method for high moisture contact. Cocona relied on the patent’s single disclosed embodiment, which described these testing methods and conditions. The Federal Circuit rejected this argument because the claim was silent regarding which MVTR method to use and  specification merely stated that MVTR “may be measured” under those conditions. The Court explained that this permissive language did not require the use of those particular testing conditions or establish when the upright or inverted method should be used[iii]. Moreover, the specification failed to explain how to distinguish between “low” and “high” moisture contact. Thus, even the single disclosed embodiment failed to provide sufficient guidance as to which measurement method and testing conditions should be used to determine whether a membrane fell within the claimed MVTR range.

The Federal Circuit made clear that it was not establishing a per se rule that claims are indefinite whenever a patent discloses multiple methods of measurement[iv]. Rather, the existence of multiple measurement methods becomes problematic when those methods produce materially different results and the patent fails to provide sufficient guidance as to which method should be used. In such circumstances, a person of ordinary skill in the art cannot determine with reasonable certainty whether a particular product falls within the scope of the claims. Thus, the mere disclosure of multiple measurement methods does not render a claim indefinite, provided the specification or prosecution history supplies sufficient guidance for determining which method applies for determining infringement of the claims.

This case builds on prior precedent such as Dow Chemical Co. v. Nova Chemicals Corp., 803 F.3d 620 (Fed. Cir. 2015). Dow also involved claims directed to a material having a particular property that could be measured using different methods. Specifically, the claims related to ethylene polymer compositions and required a slope of strain hardening coefficient greater than or equal to 1.3. The specification disclosed that the strain hardening coefficient was calculated using the slope of the strain hardening region of a stress-strain curve generated by stretching a sample of the material, but did not disclose where or how that slope should be measured along the curved region. However, extrinsic evidence established that multiple methods existed for determining the slope, each of which could produce different results. Consequently, the choice of measurement method could determine whether a particular polymer composition fell within the scope of the claims[v]. Applying the reasonable certainty standard established in Nautilus[vi], the Federal Circuit held that the claims were indefinite[vii].

Compared to the patentee in Dow, Cocona appeared to be in a stronger position: the Dow patents did not disclose how to determine the slope of strain hardening, whereas the ’287 patent expressly identified methods for measuring MVTR, referenced the ASTM E96-94 standard, and described exemplary testing conditions. Nevertheless, Cocona’s claims suffered the same fate. Cocona’s patent ultimately created uncertainty regarding claim scope because it identified multiple measurement methods that could produce substantially different results without providing sufficient guidance as to which method and testing conditions should be used. Thus, while Dow illustrates the risk of failing to adequately disclose a measurement method, Cocona demonstrates that disclosing multiple methods can be equally problematic when the specification fails to establish which method governs. In other words, the patent in Cocona was overly inclusive, leaving a person of ordinary skill in the art unable to determine with reasonable certainty which method should be used to assess whether a product fell within the scope of the claims.

From a patent drafting perspective, the patentee would have been better served by identifying a single, clearly defined test method and conditions for determining whether the claimed MVTR range was satisfied. Alternatively, multiple test methods could have been disclosed if they produced substantially equivalent MVTR values, such that the choice of method would not materially affect claim scope. The key is to ensure that the specification provides objective guidance for determining whether a product satisfies the claimed limitation, rather than leaving that determination dependent on the selection of a particular measurement method.

 

[i] Slip Op. at 2.

[ii] Id. at 7

[iii] Id. at 10

[iv] Id. at 9 n.2

[v] Dow v. Nova, 803 F.3d at 633-34.

[vi] Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc., 572 U.S. 898 (2014).

[vii] Id. at 634-635

 

About the Author

Kyle G. Konz is a shareholder in Brooks Kushman’s Patent Prosecution practice, focusing on patent prosecution, post-grant proceedings, and patent and trademark litigation in the mechanical and electromechanical arts. He works with clients ranging from Fortune 100 corporations to small businesses, preparing and prosecuting patent applications related to automotive, manufacturing, domestic appliances, and heating and cooling systems. A large part of his current post-grant and litigation work involves vehicle safety systems, connectivity, connected services, lighting, and exercise equipment. Kyle also manages trademark portfolios for several small businesses. Kyle’s engineering and hands-on experience help him quickly understand an invention and how it fits within the larger system, so he can build cohesive, valuable patent portfolios aligned with his clients’ business goals. His work is especially valuable to clients in the Automotive and Mobility Brands & Technology industry. Kyle holds a J.D., cum laude, from Wayne State University and a B.S. in Civil Engineering from Michigan State University. He was named a 2025 “Up-and-Coming Lawyer” by Michigan Lawyers Weekly.

About Brooks Kushman P.C.

Founded in 1983, Brooks Kushman P.C. has built a national reputation as a premier intellectual property and technology law firm. We accomplish this with the understanding that the most effective IP solutions come from putting great minds together – our clients and our own. With offices across the country, we forge strong relationships with corporations, small to medium-sized businesses, and leading universities.

Brooks Kushman counts a number of Fortune 100 Corporations across a variety of industries among its clients. Our attorneys have a deep understanding and broad range of experience in a variety of industries and technologies, including automotive, AI & data, automation, consumer electronics, manufacturing, medical device, computer technology, aerospace, chemicals, biotechnology, retail, food & beverage, green technology, fintech, and more. We are also recognized by leading legal publications and rankings, including, Best Lawyers, Law360, Intellectual Asset Management, Managing Intellectual Property, and World Trademark Review. For more information, please visit www.BrooksKushman.com.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.