Post-Grant Review

 
Those seeking to challenge the validity of a patent outside the courtroom have extended options, including the newly established Post-Grant Review, a counterpart to Inter Partes Review. Similar to other post-grant proceedings, a party who is not the patent owner and has not previously filed a civil action seeking a declaratory judgment of invalidity, may petition for Post-Grant Review of one or more claims. Patentability of the claims under review is decided by the PTAB. The decision can be immediately appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit by either the patent owner or the patent challenger.
 
Post-Grant Review differs from Inter Partes Review and other post-grant proceedings in that:
 
  • A petition for Post-Grant Review may be requested within nine months after the grant or reissue of a first-inventor-to-file patent.
  • The standard of review requires the petitioner to show that it is more likely than not that at least one of the claims challenged in the petition is unpatentable or, alternatively, that there is a novel or unsettled legal question that is important to other patents or patent applications.
  • Discovery may be limited to evidence directly related to factual assertions advanced by either party in the proceeding, including cited documentation, cross-examination, and information inconsistent with positions advanced during the post-grant review proceeding; and either side may move for additional discovery if the parties cannot mutually agree.
  • The petitioner’s request to cancel one or more claims of a patent may be grounded on prior art issues such as lack of novelty and obviousness (similar to an Inter Partes Review); as well as other grounds not reviewable under an Inter Partes Review proceeding, such as patent-eligible subject matter, written description, enablement, and indefiniteness. Unlike Inter Partes Review, prior art-based challenges are not limited to patents or printed publications.

Post-Grant Review Process:

review process

Strategy & Foresight

Brooks Kushman understands the intricacies and implications of post-grant challenges, how to staff such matters, what resources to deploy, and the technical issues at the heart of each matter. Our attorneys know what it takes to vigorously represent our clients and prevail in such administrative proceedings, and coordinate efforts with possible parallel district court litigation and on appeal, recognizing the impact a decision can have on a patent portfolio, market opportunities, and the bottom line. At the same time, our prosecution team works closely with our clients to develop and implement client-specific strategies to help insulate a patent portfolio from a post-grant challenge. In conjunction with our Patent Searchers, we can track related post-grant proceedings, monitor patent filings from our clients’ competitors, and search for and examine relevant prior art—to anticipate potential future challenges and institute proactive measures to minimize any potential risk. In view of the changing landscape and complex and competing interests at play, Brooks Kushman is able to leverage its depth of experience in all facets of intellectual property, to help our clients maintain competitive advantage.

  • CEO Sangeeta Shah Named In The 2021 Top 50 Women In PTAB Trials
    Wednesday, March 09, 2022

    Southfield, Mich. - Brooks Kushman is proud to announce that CEO Sangeeta Shah has been named as one of the Top 50 Women in PTAB Trials. This special recognition is released by the PTAB Bar Association’s Women’s Committee. This organization looked at women practicing before the U.S. Patent & Trademark...

  • Brooks Kushman CEO Sangeeta Shah Panelist in IPWatchdog PTAB Virtual Event in a Session on Pre-Trail Strategies
    Wednesday, April 14, 2021

    SOUTHFIELD, Michigan- Brooks Kushman CEO Sangeeta Shah served as a panelist in a recent IPWatchdog event, the PTAB Masters™ 2021: Winning at the PTAB. This event had sessions that focused on “Beating the PTAB” from the viewpoint of the patent owner. From patent prosecution strategies to harden a portfolio prior to...

  • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Andrew Turner to Present at PTAB Bar Association Virtual Annual Conference
    Thursday, September 10, 2020

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman shareholder Andrew Turner will be participating in a panel at the rescheduled PTAB Bar Association Annual Conference now slated for a virtual setting on September 24-25, 2020. The PTAB Bar Association’s Annual Conference brings together practitioners, in-house counsel, and members of the bench for a dynamic...

  • Nine Brooks Kushman Attorneys Ranked As 2020 Best Lawyer; Two Attorneys Recognized As 2020 Lawyer Of The Year
    Thursday, August 15, 2019

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman is proud to announce that the firm has been ranked in the 2020 edition of Best Lawyers list of Best Lawyers. Brooks Kushman President Frank Angileri, and shareholders Mark Cantor, Elizabeth F. Janda, John S. LeRoy, Thomas A. Lewry, Marc Lorelli, John E. Nemazi, David Randall, and Sangeeta G. Shah were listed as 2020 “Best Lawyers...

  • Brooks Kushman Recognized As Gold-Standard Firm By IAM Annual Patent 1000 For the Sixth Year in a Row; Six Attorneys Recognized As Top Practioners
    Tuesday, June 11, 2019

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman, a leading intellectual property (IP) and technology law firm, is proud to announce the firm is once again listed in Intellectual Asset Management`s (IAM) annual Patent 1000, a guide that recognizes the world`s top patent law firms and practitioners in key jurisdictions. Michigan firms were first included in the...

  • Brooks Kushman Hosts Chinese Delegation in Partnership With Michigan State University
    Friday, September 07, 2018

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman, in partnership with Michigan State University (MSU), hosted a Chinese Delegation for a roundtable discussion on Friday, September 7, 2018, in Southfield, Michigan. The roundtable focused on recent developments with U.S. patent challenges and trade secrets. It was moderated by Brooks Kushman shareholder Kristin L....

  • Brooks Kushman Recognized as Gold-Standard Firm By IAM Annual Patent 1000; Six Attorneys Recognized as Top Practioners
    Wednesday, June 06, 2018

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman, a leading intellectual property (IP) and technology law firm, is proud to announce the firms inclusion in Intellectual Asset Management`s (IAM) annual Patent 1000, a guide that recognizes the world`s top patent law firms and practitioners in key jurisdictions. Michigan firms were first included in the IAM Patent 1000...

  • Lissi Mojica Recognized in IAM Strategy 300
    Thursday, June 08, 2017

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman is pleased to announce that Principal Lissi Mojica has been listed in Intellectual Asset Management`s (IAM) annual IAM Strategy 300, a guide that recognizes those who are leaders in their community and leaders in the development and implementation of strategies that maximize the value of IP...

  • Brooks Kushman Hires Prominent IP Professional; Opens Washington D.C. Office
    Wednesday, October 12, 2016

    Southfield, Mich. – (October 12, 2016) – Brooks Kushman is pleased to announce the firm has expanded to Washington, D.C., opening its third office with the addition of Lissi Mojica. The new office is located within walking distance of the Unites States Patent and Trademark Office. The new office will be...

  • Brooks Kushman Attorneys Named “IP Stars” by Managing IP
    Wednesday, May 25, 2016

    Southfield, Mich. - Brooks Kushman is pleased to announce six of the firm’s shareholders have been named “IP Stars” by Managing Intellectual Property (IP) Magazine. This comprehensive guide to leading IP firms and lawyers covers more than 80 countries. Brooks Kushman attorneys recognized as IP Stars by the publication are President...

  • Brooks Kushman Ranked in Top 2015 PTAB Firms by Docket Navigator
    Tuesday, April 12, 2016

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. — Brooks Kushman has been named one of the top Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) law firms in a 2015 annual report published by Docket Navigator. The list includes top law firms and corporate legal departments ranked by the number of inter partes review, covered business methods,...

  • Five Brooks Kushman Attorneys Recognized as 2016 Best Lawyers in America
    Wednesday, August 19, 2015

    Southfield, Mich. -Brooks Kushman President Mark Cantor, and Shareholders Frank Angileri, Marc Lorelli, John LeRoy and Elizabeth Janda have been selected for inclusion in the 22nd edition of The Best Lawyers in America. Brooks Kushman attorneys were recognized as 2016 Best Lawyers across a variety of intellectual property (IP) practice areas,...

  • Brooks Kushman Attorneys Named "IP Stars" by Managing IP
    Sunday, May 10, 2015

    SOUTHFIELD, Mich. - Brooks Kushman is pleased to announce five of the firm’s shareholders have been named “IP Stars” by Managing Intellectual Property Magazine. This comprehensive guide to leading intellectual property (IP) firms and lawyers covers more than 80 countries. Brooks Kushman attorneys recognized as IP Stars by the publication are...

      • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Andrew Turner Quoted in Law360 on Precedential PTAB Decisions on Denials
        Friday, March 27, 2020

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman shareholder Andrew Turner was quoted in a recent Law360 article on March 26, 2020 titled, “3 Takeaways From Precedential PTAB Decisions on Denials.” In this article, experts discuss two decisions that the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) recently designated as precedential and one designated as...

      • Sangeeta G. Shah Quoted in IAM Article on Potential Changes with the Patent Trail and Appeal Board
        Monday, May 14, 2018

        SOUTHFIELD, MI – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah was featured in IAM’s May 10, 2018 article, “Change in claim construction at PTAB may not have a big practical impact but its message is clear.” The article focuses on the recent changes on the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) practices...

      • Sangeeta Shah Discusses Adverse Judgement Request
        Monday, November 21, 2016

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah was featured in Law360 November 14, 2016 article, “4 Times Patent Owners May Want Adverse Judgment At PTAB.” The article discusses the request by some patent owners to ask the Patent Trial and Appeal Board to kill claims in their own patent.  Requesting an adverse judgment can save...

      • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Discusses the Impact of the AIA and Post-Grant Proceedings in Law360
        Wednesday, November 16, 2016

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah was featured in Law360 November 15, 2016 article, “How To Prepare Patents That Can Survive AIA Reviews.” The article discusses that the passage of the America Invents Act and the post-grant proceedings it created to challenge patents has had an impact on patent prosecution. The proceedings force inventors...

      • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Discusses AIA Appeals In Law360
        Thursday, February 11, 2016

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah was featured in Law360 February 10, 2016 article, “Eyes On High Court As Fed. Circ. Again Limits AIA Appeals.”The article discusses the Federal Circuit’s recent decision in the case of Synopsys, Inc. v. Mentor Graphics Corporation that the Patent Trial and Appeal...

      • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Discusses AIA Appeals in Law360
        Monday, July 13, 2015

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah was featured in Law360 July 11, 2015 article, “5 AIA appeals to watch at the Federal Circuit.”The article discusses appeals at the Federal Circuit related to the relatively new America Invents Act. In most cases, the Federal Circuit has largely backed decisions...

      • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Discusses Patent Trolls in Crain's Detroit Business
        Tuesday, June 24, 2014

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich., - Brooks Kushman Shareholder, Marc Lorelli, was featured in an article discussing patent troll litigation in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. In the article, “Patent Trolls Take Their Toll,” Lorelli discusses how the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act protects companies against patent trolls, as well as ways that patent...

      • Brooks Kushman Earns Gold Honors in Patent 1000 Listing
        Monday, June 09, 2014

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman, intellectual property and technology law firm, is now listed in Intellectual Asset Management`s (IAM) annual Patent 1000, a guide that recognizes the world`s top patent law firms and practitioners in key jurisdictions. The 2014 IAM Patent 1000 issue marks the first time any firms from...

      • Brooks Kushman Shareholder reviews the America Invents Act in Detroit Legal News
        Thursday, April 10, 2014

        SOUTHFIELD, Mich. - In an article recently published by Detroit Legal News, Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah discusses the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA), and its effects on post-grant proceedings.In the article “Asked & Answered: Sangeeta Shah on America Invents Act,” Shah reviews the ways that the AIA has changed...

        • CEO Sangeeta Shah Presenting at PTAB Bar Association Annual Conference in D.C.
          Friday, March 11, 2022

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Chief Executive Officer, Sangeeta Shah, will be speaking during a panel discussion at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) Bar Association Annual Conference on March 24, 2022. Shah’s panel, “The Interplay between Ex Parte Reexamination and Inter Partes Review,” will explore the interplay between...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder Andrew Turner to Present at PTAB Bar Association Annual Conference
          Tuesday, February 04, 2020

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman shareholder Andrew Turner will be participating in a panel at the PTAB Bar Association Annual Conference in Washington, D.C. in March. The PTAB Bar Association’s Annual Conference brings together practitioners, in-house counsel, and members of the bench for a dynamic discussion of the Patent Trial Appeal...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder to Speak on Panel at the Managing Intellectual Property PTAB Forum
          Thursday, May 03, 2018

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Managing Intellectual Property is hosting the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) Forum 2018 in both Palo Alto and New York. The forum will discuss the impact that the America Invents Act (AIA) has had on the patent litigation landscape. Brooks Kushman shareholder Linda Mettes will be speaking on a panel...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholders to Speak at the Best Practices in Intellectual Property Sixth Annual Conference
          Wednesday, March 07, 2018

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Best Practices in Intellectual Property (BPIP) is hosting its sixth annual conference in Tel Aviv. The conference, IP Management: Today’s Global Issues, updates attendees on global  IP issues, trends and legislation. It also demonstrates practical tools, methods and new ideas that can be applied to growing and strengthening a...

        • Brooks Kushman Principal Lissi Mojica To Speak at GW Law Conference Post-Grant Practice Roundtable Discussion
          Wednesday, September 20, 2017

          Washington D.C. – Brooks Kushman principal Lissi Mojica will participate in the third annual GW Law Conference Post-Grant Practice Roundtable Discussion on September 28, 2017 in Washington D.C. at The George Washington University Law School. The half-day program consists of patent leaders from academia, industry and government to provide attendees many...

        • Brooks Kushman Principal Lissi Mojica To Speak at CPTCLA Fall CLE Seminar
          Tuesday, September 19, 2017

          Washington D.C. – Brooks Kushman principal Lissi Mojica will be presenting at The Carolina Patent, Trademark & Copyright Law Association (CPTCLA) Fall CLE Seminar on September 22, 2017 in South Carolina at the Kiawah Island Golf Resort. Her presentation is titled, “Federal Circuit Decisions and How They Are Impacting the Policies...

        • Frank Angileri to Present at Detroit FCBA Event
          Monday, March 27, 2017

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman shareholder Frank Angileri will speak on a panel discussing the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) at an intellectual property conference hosted by the Federal Circuit Bar Association’s (FCBA) and Wayne State University Law School. The conference will be held on April 19th at Wayne State...

        • Brooks Kushman Principal To Discuss the Evolution and Impact of PTAB Five Years Post-AIA
          Monday, March 20, 2017

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Principal Lissi Mojica will serve on a panel during the Practising Law Institute’s 11th Annual Patent Law Institute, at the PLI New York Center in New York, New York on April 6, 2017. The program is designed to be of practice value for those in the patent law...

        • Principal Lissi Mojica to Speak at FCBA
          Monday, January 30, 2017

          WASHTINGTON, D.C. – Brooks Kushman Principal Lissi Mojica will speak at the Federal Circuit Bar Association’s (FCBA) regional meeting at the Rocky Mountain Regional US Patent and Trademark Office in Denver, Colorado on February 17, 2017. The program will focus on current topics related to patent litigation and the Courts...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder to Discuss Post Issuance Proceedings at IP Enforcement Summit
          Tuesday, March 29, 2016

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah will serve on a panel at the Centerforce IP Enforcement Summit in Chicago on April 12, 2016 for the third consecutive year. Through the adoption of the America Invents Act (AIA), inter partes review has transformed the patent litigation landscape. Shah’s panel will...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder to Discuss Post-Grant Proceedings at IP Strategy Summit
          Thursday, May 07, 2015

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder Sangeeta Shah will serve on a panel at the Centerforce IP Strategy Summit in Chicago on May 12, 2015. The panel will focus on the proceedings for challenging patents created by the America Invents Act (AIA) and understanding how to best utilize the processes for effective defensive and enforcement strategies. Shah...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder to Discuss IP Litigation at InsideCounsel SuperConference
          Thursday, May 07, 2015

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. - Brooks Kushman Shareholder Frank Angileri will speak to attendees of the 15th annual InsideCounsel SuperConference on May 13, 2015 in Chicago. This annual conference helps legal professionals of all levels become strategic partners within their organizations.Angileri will discuss strategies for businesses to prepare for intellectual property litigation that help reduce risks and gain proactive...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder to Discuss Post-Grant Proceedings at International Women`s Leadership Forum
          Monday, June 02, 2014

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman, Shareholder Sangeeta Shah will discuss post-grant proceedings at Managing IP`s International Women`s Leadership Forum on June 6, 2014 in New York. Shah`s presentation will focus on the new post-grant proceedings created under the 2013 America Invents Act. Shah will discuss the trends that she has seen...

        • Brooks Kushman Shareholder to Serve as Panelist at the Centerforce IP Strategy Summit
          Wednesday, May 07, 2014

          SOUTHFIELD, Mich. – Brooks Kushman Shareholder, Sangeeta G. Shah, will serve on a panel at the Centerforce IP Strategy Summit in Chicago on May 13, 2014. The panel will focus on the intricacies of post-grant proceedings and its use as a powerful tool in patent litigation strategy. Shah and the other...

          • PTAB Year in Review: New Designated Decisions and Procedures Impact AIA Trial Strategies
            Friday, January 15, 2021

            While 2020 was an impactful year for everyone, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) designated numerous decisions and implemented procedural changes that affect AIA Trial Practice. These new developments include: Rule Changes (Institution, Presumptions) and Clarification Memos (Applicant Admitted Prior Art) Discretionary Denials due to Prior Examination (Advanced Bionics) and Parallel...

          • PTAB Year in Review - Designated Decisions, Constitutional Challenges, and AIA Procedures
            Monday, January 13, 2020

            The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) continued to have a meaningful impact on IP litigation in 2019 as the preferred venue for challenging validity. There were a number of significant developments at the PTAB in 2019 including: numerous designated decisions, Constitutional challenges, and several procedural updates that will affect...

          • 2018/2019 Supreme Court Intellectual Property Review
            Thursday, July 11, 2019

            The U.S. Supreme Court has concluded their term and continues to issue significant decisions affecting intellectual property.  While the Court was relatively quiet on the patent side, they did issue a number of landmark copyright and trademark decisions. During this one-hour webinar, Frank Angileri and Chanille Carswell discussed the Court’s...

          • Managing High-Stakes IP Litigation
            Monday, July 08, 2019

            Intellectual property assets, including patents, copyrights, trademark, and trade secrets, represent critical assets in today’s marketplace. Over the last several years, IP litigation has changed drastically and includes administrative proceedings that play a significant role in shaping your litigation strategy. In this webinar, Brooks Kushman IP litigators discussed how to prepare...

          • PTAB Year in Review and Looking Forward - New Procedures Require Reassessment of AIA Trial Strategies
            Monday, December 17, 2018

            During 2018, Federal Circuit and Supreme Court rulings triggered important changes to IPR and other post grant proceedings before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. In addition, the Board recently announced several new procedures that will affect AIA trial practice. These changes present new options for both petitioners and patent...

          • IP Litigation in 2019: Key Developments from 2018 and Predictions for the New Year
            Monday, December 17, 2018

            2018 was another eventful year for intellectual property litigation. In addition to developments in AIA post-grant trials before the PTAB, the Supreme Court and Federal Circuit issued several landmark decisions affecting both IP owners and accused infringers. By all indications, 2019 promises even more changes, as the Supreme Court already...

          • Strategies for Managing a Global Patent Portfolio
            Thursday, October 11, 2018

            Managing global patent portfolios is no small feat. Especially since certain emerging markets are becoming increasingly important and will play a vital role in your company’s IP strategy. In-house counsel, in cooperation with outside counsel, need to work together to accomplish your company’s business strategy and IP goals. During this webcast,...

          • Second Quarter Supreme Court and Federal Circuit IP Review
            Wednesday, June 20, 2018

            At the end of each quarter, we review significant appellate decisions during the quarter that will have the greatest impact on Intellectual Property law and practice. Watch this video to hear BK attorneys discuss the practical implications of multiple important recent rulings from the Supreme Court and the Federal Circuit,...

          • SAS And Oil States: How New Supreme Court Rulings Will Change Post-Grant Strategy
            Tuesday, May 01, 2018

            The Supreme Court’s recent decisions in SAS and Oil States mark a milestone in the evolution of AIA post grant proceedings. Although the Court affirmed the constitutionality of USPTO administrative review of issued patents, the Court also signaled that AIA trial procedures must adhere closely to the statutory framework. As...

          • What’s New on Section 101 Jurisprudence
            Wednesday, August 09, 2017

            In this webinar, the panel, including Brooks Kuhsman Shareholder David Randall, discussed updates on patent eligible subject matter since the Alice Bank, Enfish, Mayo Collaborative, and Sequenom v. Ariosa line of cases. They covered case law from federal courts, decisions from the PTAB, results of the USPTO’s roundtables last year...